Cat and the Fiddle Review

Cat and The Fiddle! If you haven’t heard of them, you must have lived in the mountains or hated Cheese. Cat and The Fiddle is the biggest online Cheesecake bakery in Singapore right now, they take pride in baking premium cheesecakes in 17 original flavors, all specially created by Singapore’s iconic dessert chef, Daniel Tay.

Reviewing 5 best-selling Cat and The Fiddle Cheesecakes that our team tried. Ranking from the best Oreo Cheesecake.

1. “The Modern Duke’s Pudding” – Oreo Cheesecake

Rating: ★★★★★ (5/5)

Price: $48.90 for 7″ cheesecake

The “Modern Duke’s Pudding”, is basically an Oreo Cheesecake, a fail-proof pairing of rich crunchy chocolate oreo cookies and cream cheese.

When has Oreo ever gone wrong! Just imagine Mcdonald’s Mcflurry in full cake form, YUMMY!

2. “Over The Moon” – New York Cheesecake

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)

Price: $45.90 for 7″ cheesecake

Cute! We absolutely love the appearance of the New York Cheesecake, don’t you think the little dots resemblance a huge block of cheddar cheese instead of the moon?

Taste-wise, we thought that with a classic new york cheesecake, we would expect more from the graham base since it’s paired with pure cream cheese. Maybe a little more buttery fragrance and a tinge more crusty texture for the base would be perfect!

3. Milo Dinosaur Cheesecake

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)

Price: $48.90 for 7″ cheesecake

OMG Milo Dinosaur! Whoever hates Milo Dinosaur, we can’t be friends.

The national favourite mamak stall drink, whoever thought of infusing a local touch onto Cheesecake, is a true genius.

The missing 1 star is for people who can differentiate the difference between Australia and Malaysia Milo powder, one being extra chocolatey, another extra milky. We prefer the extra chocolatey Australian milo powder and thought it would provide a stronger chocolate touch for the already milk-creamy cheesecake.

(Do expect a little powdery mess – we got the first-hand experience because we dip our heads in to savor the fragrance and choke on the powder, please don’t do this LOL. )

4. Maneki Neko – Tangy Lemon & Yuzu Cheesecake

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)

Price: $58.90 for 7″ cheesecake

If you’re a fan of tangy citrus flavors, this cheesecake is for you. This cheesecake is a creamier version of those fluffy Japanese cheesecakes.

Tangy and tarty, you never would have thought it would go so well together. We really love the nice tinge of citrus aroma, however, we gathered mixed reviews from our team, those who love refreshing cakes would love it. Those who are not a fan of this cake suggested that lemons just don’t go well with cream cheese.

Overall, rating for this cake is still great! Try it for yourself to decide!

5. King Cat of the Mountain – Durian (Mao Shan Wang)

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3~3.5/5)

Price: $58.90 for 7″ cheesecake

Maybe we’re a little biased because we specialize in Durian Cakes and were expecting a lot more from the highly raved national favorite.

The overall appearance and taste is definitely passable. We thought the durian taste could be stronger, but maybe it’s made lighter to ensure it doesn’t overwhelm the cream cheese goodness.

Considering a stronger Durian Cheesecake?

Cheesecake menu

Common FAQs

Placing Orders

You can place an order through their website or contact +65 6287 0077.

Customization of Cakes

No customization available.

Delivery (Cost + Time)

For next day delivery, it is free for orders above $90 and $6.90 for orders under $90

You can top up $3 for a specific next day delivery timing.

For same-day delivery, it is $7 for orders above $90 and $13.90 for orders under $90.

Operating Hours

Varies from store to store

Is Cat & the Fiddle Halal?
Cat & the Fiddle is certified MUIS Halal.

How long can you store cakes from Cat and the Fiddle after receiving it?
It is recommended to keep a cake from Cat and the Fiddle chilled for 3 days after delivery.

Can you buy a single slice of cake online?
No. But you can purchase their Fickle Feline set that comes with 10 different sets.

Can’t decide what to have? How about checking out our cakes menu here?